Choosing the Best Toys for Your Dog

Published by
min read

Find food that fits your pet’s needs

Find a dog food that fits your pet’s needs

Find a cat food that fits your pet’s needs

One of the best things about being a dog parent is how much they love to play, and choosing the best dog toys is an important part of your relationship. Whether you're playing a game of fetch or watching them roll around to entertain themselves, toys are an important part of your dog's well-being. What should you consider when choosing a dog toy?


You should always keep your dog's age in mind. A three-week-old puppy has their baby teeth, so toys with softer rubber or plush, snugly fabrics would be a good fit. From three to nine months, your puppy will be teething, so it's best to avoid hard rubber and be sure to stock up! They'll be chewing on anything they can get their paws on, so a good variety of chew toys will keep them distracted from your favourite pair of shoes.

Once teething passes, your dog will have a strong enough jaw for harder rubber toys and endless energy to play with balls or rope pulls. By age seven or so, your senior dog won't have the same jaw and tooth strength as a young adult, but it's still important to provide some softer toys to chew on and play with toys that encourage them to keep active, like easy-to-toss balls and sticks. Luckily, there are plenty of options specifically made for dogs of certain ages, all of which match your dog's age with their size and personal chewing habits.

Size and Texture

Even in adult dogs, the petite Yorkshire Terrier is unlikely to chew as harshly as the large German Shepherd, so they'll often need toys that are considered more forgiving clenched in a smaller jaw. Similarly, a toy that is too soft can break into pieces and become choked on or ingested, causing gastrointestinal blockages. If you notice a toy starting to show signs of damage such as a broken squeaker or breaks or tears in fabric or stuffing, it's best to replace it.

The right size toy is important as well. Something too small can be swallowed just as easily. A general rule is to make sure anything small enough to fit behind your dog's rear molars is a choking hazard.

Ultimately, you'll want to decide which types of toys will occupy your companion the best. Dogs, like people, will be able to indicate which toys they prefer over time.

Toy Types

Even armed with this information, navigating the toy aisle can be a bit confusing. As you shop, consider these four toy varieties with respect to the need for your individual pooch, and you'll be well on your way to finding the perfect plaything.


There are rubber balls, plush balls, tennis balls, foam balls, squeaker balls, and more. Each bounce in different ways. Some float and glow in the dark, tempting options if you have a pool or nighttime routine! This classic option is a great way to keep your dog active, too. When you find the right-sized ball for your dog, make sure it's durable enough so that it’s not chewed into tiny pieces. Balls also encourage you, as the parent, to get involved as dogs love a game of fetch or catch. This will help strengthen your bond too.

Tug Toys

Most dogs enjoy playing tug-of-war with their owners and other dogs. Although some may warn against this game to discourage aggression, PAWS suggests, there's nothing to worry about if your pup is properly trained. The most important thing to remember with tug toys is to make sure your dog doesn't tear it into pieces. Tug toys are typically plush and made of linen, leather, fire hose, or rope, so it's necessary to replace them as soon as you see damage like shredding or missing pieces. Avoid being too aggressive if you are playing tug-of-war, you never want to rip the toy out of your dog's mouth as this could cause health problems. If you want your dog to let go of the toy, you will need to train them to respond to commands such as "drop it" or "release." While a dog's jaw is very strong, it is never a good idea to pull the toy vertically and take their feet off the ground. This can cause jaw, neck and spine issues.

Treats and Chewables

Whereas anything can be a chew toy, there are some toys made specifically to be chewed on, and it's best to use them for that purpose. Generally made from nylon or hard rubber material, these items are built to last. Some can even be stuffed with treats for training and long-lasting entertainment, while others are enjoyable as is. They should be soft enough to chew with no risk of teeth breaking, but durable enough so they don't easily break down into small pieces. As your dog grows from pup to adult, you'll find you have to change the size and durability of the chew toys. Be sure you're using healthy treats in the toys to keep them extra healthy while you keep them active!


Plush toys are a favourite of many dogs, but unfortunately, they can more often than not be unsafe. As easy as they are to be ripped apart and ingested, plush toys can still be fun when fully supervised. Before your pup hits their teething phase, plush toys are a great option to give to snuggle up with at night. If your dog loves them, you shouldn't write them off right away. Just make sure your pup knows which plush toys are theirs, and not a family member's stuffed animal or pillow.

Choosing the best dog toys will ensure you both have safe, fun playtime. Toys, much like treats, can be used as a training device. If you notice your dog gravitating to a particular toy, toss it as a reward when they perform a command you've requested such as "sit." Training to understand which toys are theirs is also an important part of training. This will help guard against any destructive behaviour that might ensue from your dog chewing on things such as furniture or children's toys. Remember that your choice should depend on the age, size, and intensity of their chewing habits. Keep in mind that as your puppy ages, you'll go from puppy toys to adult toys and then even to senior toys. While safety should always come first, it should be shortly followed by fun.

Contributor Bio

Katie Finlay

Katie Finlay

Katie Finlay is a Los Angeles, CA based dog trainer and writer. She has been working with dogs and their owners both in person and through her articles for over six years.

Related Articles

  • Key Tips to Keep Your Puppy Fit & Healthy

    Keep your new puppy in great shape by following our healthy puppy tips, including information about exercise, nutrition, and eating habits.
  • Exercise Ideas for Your Large-Breed Dog

    If you have a Great Dane, Greyhound, Boxer or other large or giant breed dog, there’s probably nothing you both enjoy more than getting outside and exercising together. It helps keep both of you healthy while building your relationship as well.
  • Show Your Love And Exercise Your Dog

    Prevent canine obesity and health issues by staying active with these fun tips for exercising your dog, at every life stage.
  • Ideas for Playing With Puppies Outside

    Get ready to discover fun activities you can have with your new puppy outdoors while learning how to keep him safe and happy.

Related products